
Aircraft carriers are ‘vulnerable to attack’, per the news story. No! Really! Like, we don’t know that already? Yes, I know, that’s the USS Mahan, but I couldn’t find a bird farm photo in the bin.
http://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-trump-carriers-specialreport-idUSKBN16G1CZ
From the article: “Trump’s expansion plans come as evidence mounts that potential enemies have built new anti-ship weapons able to destroy much of the United States’ expensive fleet of carriers. And as they have been for decades, carriers remain vulnerable to submarines.
In a combat exercise off the coast of Florida in 2015, a small French nuclear submarine, the Saphir, snuck through multiple rings of defenses and “sank” the U.S. aircraft carrier Theodore Roosevelt and half of its escort ships. In other naval exercises, even old-fashioned diesel-electric submarines have beaten carriers.”
The ignorance of this reporter and others is glaringly obvious in this story. A task force is built to deal with these kinds of things.
Ships at sea are and always have been vulnerable to attack and to damage, as is shown in the WWII damage report on the Enterprise CV-6.
https://www.history.navy.mil/research/library/online-reading-room/title-list-alphabetically/w/war-damage-reports/uss-enterprise-cv6-war-history-1941-1945.html
Go to page 51 in the report, photo #2 J2. This was shot during the Battle of (Midway). Sorry, that should be the Battle of Okinawa. My bad.
The 9-ton elevator door was blown skyward by kamikaze pilot’s suicide strike, after the bomb his plane was carrying exploded in the hangar deck. The elevator door is at the top of the explosion column in the still photo, which is a frame taken from a 16mm film being shot at the time. While you’re at it, look at some of the damage Japanese bombs did to that old girl. Note in the damage report how many times Enterprise suffered damage throughout the battles in which she was involved and still hung in there, no matter what.
The lesson is that the press seem to insist on being uninformed and/or misinformed, as an excuse for writing sensationalist articles like this. Frankly, in a real war, I would expect diesel subs to be used because not every country has nuclear subs. Russia has five nuclear subs, but only one aircraft carrier.
As indicated in the article, the Chinese are claiming they have missiles that can go 10 times the speed of sound, which is 761.2 mph (1,227.74 km/h). That means their missiles are, per their claim, able to move at 7,612 mph.. That’s their claim, no evidence that it’s true is available to date.
Fastest missile speed to date is BrahMos. between Mach 2.8 (3,400 km/h; 2,100 mph; 0.95 km/s) and Mach 3 (3,700 km/h; 2,300 mph; 1.0 km/s). These are for ship, submarine, aircraft (under testing) and land-based mobile launchers. BrahMos is a cruise missile of Indian/Russian origins.
Peak speed for ICBMs is 6 to 7 km/sec, which is 13,392 mph or 21,600kph. Any faster, and the missile launches into space.
Unless there’s something under development that can move that fast and track a Nork ICBM, what is our alternative? Anyone have the answer? Anyone? Bueller?
With Fatty Kim da T’ird getting jiggy on his side of the Chinese-Norkiland border, and the Chinese showing a bit of angst about it (because they don’t want to be bothered with him, either), it’s logical to ask if we, meaning the USA, have anything that can track and destroy an ICBM moving at 13,392 miles per hour. Thugboy is leading up to the intercontinental stage of missile development and if he gets a hair up his ass, he’s going to launch ‘em. He won’t just be shooting at the South, or the Chinese or Japan. His aspirations go much further than that. It would be no real loss if he accidentally took out some part of SoCalifornia, instead of Foggy Bottom.
But to return to the story itself, the reporter misunderstands the purpose of war games, which is to test the vulnerability of your own armaments as well as those of your opponents. His quivering, panicky prose indicates a lack of information.
It may be that he likes to be that way. It stokes his little adrenaline rushes, or something. Perhaps he should watch ‘Down Periscope’ a couple of times.