The whole argument over John Hawkins’ “Top 25 Worst Americans” strikes me as positively absurd, and yet apparently it has been on Memeorandum for like 3 days. Whatever. Seems to me when you write to a bunch of political bloggers and ask their opinion on something, it will come with an implied political perspective. We’re not historians, we’re political bloggers. Well, whatever. (I think quite clearly the 4 worst Americans are the lawyer who managed to outlaw Lawn Jarts, Peyton Manning, the genius that came up with “Jersey Shore” and James Woods.)
Largely I avoided the whole controversy by virtue of the fact that Jonn is a dick and doesn’t include me on such things. He is also a gay bird, Tony Romo’s Bitch, a former pilot in Strike Fighter Squadron 136, and married to Nathan Lane in Massachusetts. No wait, actually I think that was the dude I wrote about last week, and possibly Peter Griffin who was enjoying the spirit of Massachusetts while on a vacation from Quahog.
None-the-less, I did stop by HotAir this weekend just to make sure I wasn’t missing any vital news. I was not. However, I did read this post by Jazz Shaw wherein he blasts the list. I actually didn’t read it all, but skipped down to his list, which had John Wilkes Booth as #1 and Nathan Bedford Forrest as #2. Well, I have defended Forrest before, so I decided to do so again. I actually wrote to Mr. Shaw who was kind enough to reply. Specifically I wanted to know what made Forrest so odious that he was included, whether it was the alleged KKK nonsense or the “Ft Pillow Massacre.”
His reply in part read:
I have no doubt that a careful analysis of the life of NBF could turn up some fascinating and perhaps even admirable aspects. But I’m afraid that – at least for many of us- none of it can manage to overshadow the defining aspect of being the man who essentially reconstituted the Klan.
Well, that sounded like a fun place to start, since no one ever accused him of reconstituting the Klan, and there is significant historical debate over his role in the KKK at all. (More on that in a minute.) Anyway, I went back to the post and read it in full to get more context. In that post Jazz links to this post by Rick Moran.
Now, as far as I know, I’ve never read Rick Moran. I’ve seen his name bandied about occasionally, but I don’t remember actually reading him. The only reason I even remember the name is because I once thought “Glad to see he came up with something to do after Ghostbusters and shrinking his kids.”
Anyway, Rick thinks Jonn and I are idiots, which is horrifically injurious to my psyche, because I derive all self-worth from what people on the internet I’ve never heard of say about me. Needless to say, after reading his post, I did my version of the crying game shower, and then spent the bulk of the weekend in the fetal position crying and watching Spongebob. He entitled this epic masterpiece “THE TOP 43 DUMBEST CONSERVATIVE BLOGGERS”
(more…)
