Crossposted…..
This is actually an update to a story that started over a year ago. You might remember it from some of the TV coverage at the time, but in case you don’t, here is one story about it:
So, the girl was supposed to say the Mexican pledge, and sing the Mexican National Anthem. She didn’t, and failed. She has now filed suit, and I will address that below, but about the pledge and anthem, there are two things that deserve note.
Regarding the pledge, it is interesting to note that had this girl been required to salute the US Flag and do the pledge, this would have been unquestionably unconstitutional. In fact, the Supreme Court ruled in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette, 319 U.S. 624(1943) that compulsory requirements to pledge to the flag by school children violated the first Amendment. It’s astonishing to me that this school district somehow thought that a compulsory pledge to another flag would somehow by just fine. Further, as my friend Dr. John Fonte noted in a November 2005 piece entitled “Dual Allegiance: A Challenge to Immigration Reform and Patriotic Assimilation“:
Dual allegiance is incompatible with the moral basis of American constitutional democracy because 1) Dual allegiance challenges our core foundation as a civic nation (built on political loyalty) by promoting an ethnic and racial basis for allegiance and, thus, subverts our “nation of (assimilated) immigrants” ethic; and 2) Dual allegiance violates the core American principle of equality of citizenship.
So the pledge is bad. Arguably worse though is the Mexican National Anthem, which contains in the First and Fith stanzas these lines:
But if some enemy outlander should dare to profane your ground with his sole, think, oh beloved Fatherland!, that heaven has given you a soldier in every son….War, war without quarter to any who dare to tarnish the coats of arms of the country! War, war! Let the national banners be soaked in waves of blood. War, war! In the mountain, in the valley, let the cannons thunder in horrid unison and may the sonorous echoes resound with cries of Union! Liberty!
Now, I have no big problem with the martial nature of the lyrics, since our National Anthem is not especially peace-like either. But then again, we don’t force British folk to sing our national anthem. The Mexican National Anthem was written in 1854, and all the stuff about war is a direct reference to the battles they had just held with the Americans. So basically this Texas high school, whose inclusion into the United States is what started this war in the first place, is requiring this young lady to sing a song which glorifies the killing of 13,283 US Citizens. That to me is unconscionable. (If you want to learn more about that war, I recommend to you Jeff Shaara’s Gone for Soldiers which I happened to be rereading just as this story came out again.)

