Keeping in mind that the vast majority of Americans who will actually get off their ass and vote have already made up their minds, I watched the debate from a different perspective.
I’ll have to give round one to McCain, actually a fairly solid victory.
McCain came out slow but finished well; not too much surprised me from McCain. McCain lacks a killer instinct and missed several opportunities to crush the neophyte senator with a clue bat.
What surprised me most was how clearly flustered and frankly amateurish Obama came off. He failed to defend his near-trillion dollars worth of pork, his no-no-no energy policy and his tax policy which would be disastrous.
That was on the economic part.
On the national security/foreign policy part….
McCain stomped a mud hole in his puny ass and then walked it dry.
“Let me get this straight, we’re gonna sit down with Ahmadinejad and when he says he wants to wipe Israel off the map; we’re gonna say No you’re not”. Oh please!”
Then McCain caught Obama lying about Kissinger’s position and called him on it.
That’s the “inside baseball” view of someone who stays on top of politics.
None of this matters to the target; the undecided/independents. These voters look at these things much differently.
From this perspective, I agree with Charles Krauthammer, it was pretty much a non-event.
McCain did a poor job of talking to the camera (the folks) while Obama did a fairly good job of that.
McCain came across energetic and did not lose his composure or sense of humor while Obama appeared to get visibly angry at least once.
The end state was no great sound bites or huge gaffes, thus non-event.
I don’t think this debate will boost the polls either way.
The careful, measured tone of both of the candidates last night was likely viewed by most undecideds as boring. The viewership of the next McCain/Obama debate will struggle to achieve 50% of last night.
The October 2nd VP debate is now the game changer.
If Palin doesn’t vastly improve over her interview with Katie Couric, McCain is in big trouble.
On the other hand, Obama has to be terrified that his entire campaign could be in the hands (or mouth in this case) of Joe Biden.
It is likely that the most nervous people in America in October 2nd will be McCain and Obama.