Category: Veterans Issues

  • Ohio Court: ‘No’ to Jeffrey Belew’s PTS excuse

    Ohio Court: ‘No’ to Jeffrey Belew’s PTS excuse

    Jeffrey-Belew

    The Toledo Blade reports that the Ohio Supreme Court didn’t accept the excuse that Jeffrey Belew’s shootout with police in Oregon, Ohio was the result of PTS which he claimed stemmed from his tour in Iraq in 2008. The court refused to take up the appeal by a 4-3 vote. The majority didn’t issue a statement on the decision, but the minority did;

    “I would respectfully suggest that one trial court judge, three appellate court judges, and the majority of this court simply do not get it,” [Justice William O’Neill] wrote. “PTSD is not an excuse. It is an explanation.

    “There is more at stake here than garden-variety excuses for criminal culpability,” he wrote. “Belew was a marginal Marine recruit; he developed PTSD while on active duty; and he was turned out of the service with a bad-conduct discharge and little or no capacity to function safely in society.”

    Justice O’Neill continued that the military “took a marginal recruit from an abusive family and turned him into a fighting machine.” He claimed that the shootout was an attempted “suicide by cop”. Well, except that people with PTS don’t normally try to hurt others and Belew actually tried to shoot officers.

    According to prosecutors, Belew had a history of violent behavior as a juvenile offender before he joined the Marines. As a juvenile, the military wouldn’t have been informed of that history. The judge said that “PTSD is not an excuse. It is an explanation.” Well, it looks to me as if Belew is using PTS as an excuse for his bad behavior, if the prosecutor is to be believed and the Ohio Supreme Court made the correct decision, a decision best for the veteran community – you know, the vast majority of us who don’t use our military experiences as an excuse for our bad decisions.

  • Tahmooressi to remain in jail

    Tahmooressi to remain in jail

    Tahmooressi

    Yesterday, Marine Sergeant Andrew Tahmooressi finally had his day in court in Mexico after being imprisoned for 102 days because, by his own account, he accidentally drove into Mexico with a few weapons and several boxes of ammunition. Yesterday, the judge ordered him back to his cell, according to Fox News;

    Despite the judge’s ruling, Tahmooressi’s attorney, Fernando Benitez, told reporters that he was confident that the Marine’s case was on the right track. Benitez said that his client’s statement to the judge was “sound and made perfect sense,” and claimed that irregularities with Tahmooressi’s detention were grounds for dismissal of the case. The attorney said that his client was not provided with consular services for nearly eight hours after he was detained, nor did he have access to an adequate translator.

    In addition, Benitez said that the order to search Tahmooressi’s vehicle was dated March 28, three days before the Marine crossed the border.

    From the LA Times;

    Some 74 members of U.S. Congress have called on the Obama administration to work with Mexican authorities to gain Tahmooressi’s release.

    On the eve of Wednesday’s hearing, Rep. Lee Terry, R-Neb., and Rep. Duncan Hunter, R-Calif., wrote to the Mexican judge, Victor Octavio Luna Escobedo, reminding him that Tahmooressi is “a Marine Corps veteran who risked his life for his nation and his fellow Marines.”

  • Erik Katz wants your money

    Erik Katz

    So this fresh-faced fellow, Erik Katz, who has never spent a day in uniform joins in with every other fucknut who thinks they know about military service and decides that he knows how to save the Pentagon from sequestration. Of course, his intellect is mud-puddle deep, so like all of the other dorks, goes straight to personnel cuts;

    The most significant compensation reduction option, CBO found, would come from cutting retirement pay for veterans already receiving disability payments from the Veterans Affairs Department. Prior to 2004, military retirees — former personnel with 20 years of service — had their retirement pay reduced by the amount of any VA disability compensation they also received. Moving back to that system would save Defense $108 billion over the next decade, according to CBO.

    The non-partisan budget office said the current system compensates disabled veterans twice for their service, but the two payments reward “different characteristics of military service.”

    We, in the business call it “concurrent receipt”, Erik, and it took decades to straighten that stuff out. What baby-face GWU-grad here wants to happen is veterans who are more than 50% disabled would be made to fund their own disability from their retirement pay because people who have a disability less than 50% already have their retirement pensions reduced by the amount of their disability payments.

    You know what I would do if I was looking to save money for the government and I wanted to look like a smart guy (instead of throwing in with the rest of the hacks)? I’d stop trying to hammer the little guy. I’d write about how much money could be saved if we cut retirement benefits for Congress members. I’d figure how much could be saved if we cut costs on the lavish lifestyle of flag officers and their staffs. I certainly wouldn’t go after disabled veterans who can’t work and depend on every penny they get in return for their service and sacrifice. But, hey, how can I expect some pimple-faced, snot-nosed journalism student to understand what sacrifice means, right? Shame on me.

    Oh, GFY, Erik.

  • About Berghdal’s “Reintegration” . . . .

    Berghdal has lately been “out and about” as part of his “reintegration”. Well, I guess that’s . . . OK. Sorta. Maybe.

    Bergdahl has been back under US control for nearly a month now. An Army MG has been appointed to investigate his . . . well, let’s just say “unusual” disappearance in Afghanistan.

    So I wonder: how’s that investigation coming? I mean, there aren’t that many soldiers who were members of his unit and were at Berghdal’s location when he disappeared. So even if they’re out of the military, they’ve certainly been contacted by now – right?

    Um, well – not exactly . Seems no one has contacted them yet.

    For some reason, the terms “Tom Sawyer” and “fence” keep coming to mind. But maybe that’s just a coincidence.

  • Parminder Singh Shergill and the crazed vet myth

    Parminder Singh Shergill and the crazed vet myth

    Parminder-Singh-Shergill

    You may remember that several months ago, in California Sikh Parminder Singh Shergill was killed by police when he threatened them with a knife. He was a combat veteran, and of course, everyone in the media and his family blamed “PTSD” and the government’s failure to treat him properly for the incident, like this headline from New India Times;

    Parminder Singh Headline

    And this line from the Sacramento Bee;

    “It’s not the Lodi police who let this young man down,” [Kuldeep Dhatt, president of Lodi’s Sikh Temple] said. “It’s the country. He was a veteran, and he didn’t receive proper treatment. A young man’s life is lost. It’s a wrongful death however you look at it. But we have to move forward and start looking for solutions, and that was what we hoped this meeting would accomplish.”

    Yeah, well, we got his military records and he may have had mental problems, but it probably wasn’t PTS. He was a Gulf War I veteran, but he was a generator mechanic in a support battalion;

    Parminder Singh FOIA

    Parminder Singh Assignments

    I find it difficult to believe that anything happened to him in that position that would cause him to have PTS. But, hey, PTS explains everything, right? All veterans are victims. And the explanation lets the police off the hook for not using something less lethal than bullets on a crazed veteran Sikh with a knife.

    As long as everything a veteran does is somehow related to PTS, we’re never going to overcome the myths that revolve around veterans and the “crazed veteran” stereotypes. This guy was probably a little crazy, but it wasn’t related to being a generator mechanic in a support battalion for five months.

  • VFW: Boycott Mexico

    The Washington Times reports that the Veterans of Foreign Wars is calling for a boycott on travel to and products from Mexico until former Marine Sergeant Andrew Tahmooressi is released from his imprisonment there. He was arrested by Mexican authorities when he accidentally crossed in Mexico carrying firearms and ammunition.

    “This combat Marine has been languishing away since he was arrested March 31 for allegedly crossing the border accidentally with three personal firearms that were legally registered in the [U.S.] but not in Mexico,” said VFW National Commander William A. Thien. “It was a mistake, but so is the Mexican government’s reluctance to release him unharmed back to the U.S.”

    Mr. Thien added that the VFW has already attempted to negotiate the release politically, asking President Obama to contact Mexican President Enrique Pena Nieto, but said that that phone call never took place.

    Did I mention that Mexican police regularly cross the US/Mexico border “accidentally”?

    According to Homeland Security numbers, there have been 300 incursions by Mexican police or troops since Jan. 1, 2004. The Mexicans were armed in slightly more than half of those incidents, totaling 525 people. There was a verbal or physical altercation between U.S. authorities and the Mexicans in 81 instances — totaling 320 Mexican police or troops.

  • CPT Benjamin Summers on hero worship

    Captain Benjamin Summers is an Aviation officer at Fort Campbell, KY and he felt a need to tell us in the pages of the Washington Post that not all veterans are heroes;

    Over the past decade, a growing chasm between military and civil society has raised the pedestal upon which the United States places those who serve in its military. Too much hero-labeling reinforces a false dichotomy that’s commonly heard in our political discourse: You’re either for the troops or you’re against them. We badly need to find ways to bridge this civilian-military gap to cultivate a more nuanced appreciation of service and to produce better policy in Washington.

    […]

    [T]he widening civil-military divide intensifies the aura that attaches to military service, especially when the country is at war. Over the past decade, veterans did many things that the general public didn’t do and doesn’t necessarily comprehend fully: deploying, being away from home for a year, serving in war zones. During these years, it’s undeniable that veterans have received a hero’s embrace from their nation….

    I know the Captain probably has the best of intentions, and that he’s trying to make the public debate over the future of the military in the country a bit more clear, but he’s not being helpful, especially when he writes in the Washington Post. Let me explain to the pup about my perspective on the issue.

    I say “pup” because he’s not old enough to remember the post-Vietnam Era when the complete opposite was true – whether you were a Ranger in the bush rooting out the Viet Cong or you were a sailor floating off shore, and never saw a single Vietnamese tree, the American public thought of you as a “baby-killer”. Despite what the Left would have you believe, there were soldiers returning to this country to a shower of spittle.

    There was no discussion of veterans getting the benefits they deserved. The war was over and no one wanted to talk about them. There really were homeless and substance-abusing veterans, and no one really cared. The Veterans’ Service Organizations shouted about the problem, but no one was listening. Some of the VSOs didn’t even recognize them as real veterans. Families were divided over their service. Hollywood portrayed them as lunatics who played Russian Roulette in their spare time. One movie used a legless veteran whose wife was cheating on him with a 4Fer as the villain.

    No beggar on the street would tug at your purse strings with a sign that identified him as a veteran. Being a veteran was worse than being a homeless bum in that particular America.

    Our military budget was slashed to the bone with no debate, so that we trained to fight with Korean War-era equipment and weapons. When I got promoted from E-4 to E-5, my pay shot up $22/month. We practiced assembling on the drop zone by jumping from the back of a duece-and-a-half as it drove down Sicily Drop Zone because there was no money for the 82nd Airborne Division to jump from aircraft.

    On the other hand, just the other day, the “for or against the troops” thing saved the A-10 Warthog from the scrap yard for another year. I’d say that was a good thing…for the troops, those ground pounders who you admit really are heroes.

    So, yeah, the pendulum is swinging wide in the opposite direction as it did after Vietnam, but you tell me, which direction is better in regards to our national defense? The American public that doesn’t go to war will never understand those who do…there will always be a divide. But the way it is now is a damn-sight better than it has been in our history. So, just leave it be, young buck.

    And, the Washington Post is not your friend. The Post and their readers don’t need your help to bring the troops down off the pedestal.

    Thanks to Chief Tango for the link.

  • Vets flood Legion’s Arizona crisis center

    Vets flood Legion’s Arizona crisis center

    In case you didn’t know it, The American Legion set up a crisis center in Phoenix to help veterans and the Department of Veterans’ Affairs hospital there catch up on appointments. According to the Associated Press it’s going gangbusters down there.

    “Unfortunately, we have to be here,” Verna Jones, the director of veteran’s affairs and rehabilitation for the national American Legion, told the crowd at the crisis center in Phoenix on Tuesday. “But fortunately, we’re here to help you with the services that you deserve.”

    Jones addressed a packed room filled with veterans seeking help to expedite their care through the VA while many complained they felt as if they had fallen through the cracks.

    “It hurts us to have just one vet stand up and say, `I’m dying because the VA failed me,’” Jones said. “They’re frustrated, they’re concerned and they just don’t know where to go.”

    The American Legion said it will operate the crisis center in Phoenix through Friday and expects to assist hundreds of veterans, possibly extending the program to other cities.