Category: Rethink Afghanistan

  • Time is Not on Our Side

    Time is Not on Our Side

    A little over a week ago, a bomb rocked the city of Kabul.  As of April 25th, 64 are dead and over 300 were injured.  Despite the fact that the target of the attacks was a security team that protects government VIPs, the majority of the victims are reportedly women and children.

    In response to the attack, The commander of NATO forces in Afghanistan, Gen. John W. Nicholson, stated:

    “Today’s attack shows the insurgents are unable to meet Afghan forces on the battlefield and must resort to these terrorist attacks,”

    Similarly, Afghan President Mohammad Ashraf Ghani condemned the attack and tweeted this.

    “Today’s terrorist attack…clearly shows the enemy’s defeat in face-to-face battle.”

    Finally, to further “control” the narrative, the U.S. Embassy in Kabul released the following statement:

    “Afghanistan deserves peace and security, not attacks that victimize parents taking their children to school, workers on their morning commute, and people who have stepped forward to help defend their fellow citizens,”

    With the continued withdraw of a military presence from Afghanistan, no one should be surprised that soft targets, which used to take the form of military supply convoys in rural Afghanistan, are now Afghan security units inside the Afghan Capital.

    The attack came a week after the official start to “Operation Omari” (named after the late Taliban founder Mullah Mohammad Omar) which also coincided with the annual spring offensive AKA the fighting season.

    The Taliban described the operation as “[employing] all means at our disposal to bog the enemy down in a war of attrition that lowers the morale of the foreign invaders and their internal armed militias.”

    I think this statement perfectly defines what this war, from the Taliban’s perspective, has always been about.

    From the very beginning, as U.S. aircraft bombed the hell out of the Taliban, the enemy knew they could never defeat a Western military on the field of battle.  Instead, they adopted a strategy that focused on bogging us down, attrition and lowering morale.

    Afghan history taught the Taliban that whether it was the Brits, Soviets or Americans, foreign invaders would eventually tire of war and leave.

    As an American who has both a reverence for war and military history, I can appreciate the commitment to the enemy’s strategy because it is the same one General George Washington implemented to defeat the British Army during The American Revolutionary War.

    The strategy employed by both the Taliban and American revolutionaries is very reminiscent of the approach that Fabius Maximus utilized to defeat Carthaginian general Hannibal during the Second Punic War—dubbed The Fabian Strategy.  The Fabian strategy avoided decisive engagements, utilized terrain to nullify the enemy’s superior Cavalry, and focused on softer targets like foraging units.

    Of course, I’m not arguing that there was a moral equivalency between American revolutionary soldiers and the Taliban.  On the contrary, the Taliban has repeatedly demonstrated that they have no qualms about killing innocent civilians while fighting their war.  However, both insurgencies were determined to endure and banked on the enemy’s weariness of battle.  I also realize outside support from the French (for American insurgents) and Iran, Pakistan, and foreign Jihadists (for the Taliban) also facilitated in both insurgency’s ability to “go the distance.”

    My main point is to highlight that after 15 years, we have the NATO commander in Afghanistan—an American Army General—attempting to underscore that the Taliban’s terrorist attacks are a sign of weakness.

    No, it does, however, demonstrate that the insurgency is launching attacks inside an area that was previously considered a hard target and inaccessible in earlier stages of the war.

    With all due respect sir, the Taliban is not “unable” to meet Afghan forces on the field of battle; they simply are—strategically—choosing not to.  Americans are beyond exhausted with the Afghan war, and the enemy knows it.

    Like the British before us, time has become our greatest enemy and their greatest commodity.

  • Daily Dose of Delusion. (Updated)

    So once again the the people over at Our Journey to Smiles are doubling down on the delusions. The main one is that somehow that all the woes in Afghanistan are because out outside forces and interference. Their latest video states as much.

    Why do we spend money like this? Why don’t we use an alternative way? The international community says that drones are used to kill the Taliban. This is not true. We should see the truth. Today, it’s hard to find the truth and no one listens to the people.They kill human beings. Drones bring nothing but bombs. They burn the lives of the people. People can’t move around freely. In the nights, people are afraid. Drones don’t improve people’s lives, they limit the people’s lives. The people are not happy with drones. When they hear the sound of drones, they feel sad.
    Drones don’t protect the people of Afghanistan. Instead, drones kill the people of Afghanistan. You hear in the news and reports that every day, families, children and women are killed. Do you call this safety?

    So you see because of international intervention it led to the deaths of twelve people at a local party and a local teacher from a Girls school.

    But on a serious note I thought that the majority of the drone strikes were in Pakistan and not in Afghanistan. And since my frienemy is no longer working with Rethink Afghanistan so I am not sure if they are still working with Journey to Smiles.

    UPDATE: This comment from the video is a good example of what happens when history is forgotten.

    Sporkmater you’re missing the point here: drones are killing innocent people, whose relatives will not think of the US better for it. No wonder the Taliban has regained so much support.

    On a seperate note, I’m willing to bet that the Taliban would not allow so called agricultural ‘aid’ that is going to poison the whole ecosystem and economy with Roundup pesticides and GMO-slavery. So? yea, maybe they will be better off with the Taliban in charge. Who is to say?

  • Delusions from desperation.

    Well it seems that the full understanding of what life will be like after we leave Afghanistan is hitting home at Journey to Smiles. It seems that their newest video is showing that more then ever.

    The biggest one is trying to have a campaign to get two million friends here and have them send a petition to the UN to have the UN “to negotiate a end to the Afghanistan War”. You know, since it has been so effective with Syria. Also it seems this groups has tried to contact the UN in Afghanistan without any reply back. That was back in April and I am not sure what they are expecting now.

    The rest of the video has different women talking about how the are treated and viewed in Afghanistan. Then someone suggest that a sports program might help can calling it “A Contest of Peace”. Yet I could have sworn that this was done before somewhere. Then there is the question that everyone is avoiding that one of them asked; “Is this something we are doing to pass the time?”.

  • The Jake Diliberto fairy tales

    I wrote about Jake Diliberto a few weeks back. He’s one of the founders of “Veterans for Rethinking Afghanistan” which is a group of veterans who seek to have the US withdraw from Afghanistan. He appears on al Jazeera, the old, failed Olbermann show and Russia TV, like the clip above in which the presenter at about 1:18 into the video calls Jake an “Iraq and Afghanistan veteran”. Here’s screen shot that Hondo found from Jake’s time in college when he told the publication’s writer that he was in the Marines as a special operator;

    And here’s his HuffPO profile which says that Diliberto is a veteran of Afghanistan and Iraq;

    EDITOR’S NOTE: Since I first took the above screen shot of Diliberto’s bio on HuffPo, he’s changed it to read that he served in “Af/Pak” in 2001 because I told him that I was publishing this and sent him a copy of the draft of this post.

    I’m having trouble getting his records, but I’ve got something better – I’m getting emails from his former platoon sergeant and squad leader and his battalion commander who tell me things that I wouldn’t find in his records anyway. It seems that Jake was a big shitbird and he was a shitbird before the war against terror even began.

    Some folks overheard him telling his mother that he was calling from a secret mission in Cuba in the Spring of 2001. When this was reported to his squad leader, Diliberto was punished for lying to his mother by being placed on guard duty, during which he fell asleep and was rewarded with Non-judicial punishment (NJP) which means he was fined and restricted with, perhaps some extra duties.

    In another incident, he was telling stories to a person he thought was a civilian about his time with Force Recon. Turns out that she was actually the battalion commander’s daughter. The BC was pretty angry about that and called him on the carpet.

    His squad leader also caught him on leave wearing a Force Recon T-shirt on his way home when he thought he was safe from his unit’s scrutiny.

    The unit deployed immediately after 9-11 by ship. his leaders put him on duty in the kitchen of the ship where he intentionally lanced his hand to get out of working there. When they got to Pakistan prior to their deployment into Afghanistan, Diliberto locked and loaded his weapon and threatened his corporal which resulted in the unit giving him another NJP action and included a bust to Private. His unit went on to Afghanistan while Diliberto went back to working in the ship’s kitchen.

    In 2002, when his unit got back on the ship, they heard stories from the sailors with whom he interacted about his wild tales of daring-do in Afghanistan. they also discovered evidence that he was emailing back to the States the same tales and that he was working with SEALs, so they took away his privileges to put an end to his antics. For the remainder of the cruise, Diliberto spent his time on paint duty. Here’s a statement from one of his senior sergeants describing his shitbird behavior;
    (more…)

  • Not smiling Now.

    A while ago I found a group called Journey to Smiles. I havewritten about them and how they seem to be happy and cheerful. Well not so much now. I guess it is hard when you have to deal with reality rather then living in never land.

    On and it seems that they have a video that claimed that they are still playing the tool for groups like Rethink Afghanistan with videos like this. Yea when I first read about them they seemed misguided but their hearts in the right place, now they are just a political tool that will be thrown away when their use is done.

  • Jake Diliberto; the Matthis of Rethink Afghanistan

    Someone, who wants to remain anonymous, contacted me last night on Facebook. The gentleman told me that he was Jake Diliberto’s unit when the unit deployed to Afghanistan. Jake Diliberto is one of the founders of the organization “Rethink Afghanistan” which opposes the war against terror in Afghanistan.

    Jake has been on Larry King, al Jazeera and Russia TV using his supposed service in Afghanistan as his “moral authority” on speaking to that issue. We’ve written about him in the past. Most recently, he was quoted by Adam Weinstein in Mother Jones, as Jake is also a Ron Paul supporter – another one of those combat veterans for Ron Paul. And Diliberto is a pal of Adam Kokesh. Anyway, here’s Diliberto on Larry King. King tells his audience that Diliberto is an Iraq and Afghanistan veteran at about 1:45 into the video;

    Anyway, this person on Facebook told me last night that their Marine Corps unit did deploy to Afghanistan, but that Diliberto only got as far as Pakistan, when he fell asleep on guard duty and his leadership lost confidence in him and sent him back to the ship to pull kitchen duty while they continued on to Afghanistan.

    I contacted Diliberto this morning to verify this information, he deleted my post to his wall saying that he didn’t want “hate mail” on his FB page. Of course, it wasn’t “hate mail”, I just asked Jake if it was true.

    So we had a PM discussion on FB and all he would tell me is that the story is inaccurate. He wouldn’t explain how it was inaccurate. I asked him if he had been to Iraq, he responded that he had, but that his records showed that he was in Kuwait and not Iraq and that he was a “security augment” and not involved in combat operations. I told him he should show me his DD214 and he wanted me to make the trip to DC to see it. When I said he could email it to me, he dropped the subject abruptly.

    Diliberto claimed that he had tried to be honest about his military service, but if you watched the video of the Larry King Show, did anyone notice whether or not Jake corrected Larry when he said Jake was an Iraq and Afghanistan War veteran? And where would Larry get the idea that Jake had deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan if Jake hadn’t told one of the producers that before the show?

    When I made the point that Jake is no better than Matthis, he got huffy. But at least Matthis was inside Afghanistan, no matter how briefly. Jake never made it that far and still calls himself an Afghanistan veteran.

    So sorry, I don’t have paperwork, but I could publish the Facebook discussion I had with Jake and you can judge for yourself how much of this is true or not. Like I said, he only told me that the story was inaccurate, but he wouldn’t tell me how it was inaccurate. He didn’t deny that he wasn’t deployed to Afghanistan, so this guy who came to me last night says he can assemble several others who served with Diliberto to verify his account. Diliberto won’t even send me his DD214 to prove them wrong. Yep, it’s all circumstantial, but the circumstances aren’t Diliberto’s friends.

  • It is easy to be brave…

    When you are not the one doing it. But that does not stop people from telling people to do what they are afraid to do themselves.

    Hey, #occupydc…lots of weapons dealers hawking their wares to govt at Wash. Convention Center this week. Just sayin. http://ow.ly/6SR3Y

    Yea I did not see your picture in the “Occupy Austin” so what was your excuse?

    Or trying to blame the military spending for the failure of the green jobs that were suppose to bring us back to economic recovery?

    These stories will proliferate as the military contractor corporations push to protect their profits. When you see them, PUSH BACK. Military spending *costs jobs* compared to other ways of spending the money.

    It is so easy to tell people what to do when you are not the one doing it.

  • What a peace message from the Taliban looks like.

    So it seems that the Taliban have killed Burhanuddin Rabbani, chairman of Afghanistan’s High Peace Council

    Rabbani, a former Afghan national leader, was killed and his deputy wounded as “they met two men who said they had come from Quetta, Pakistan, with a peace message from the Taliban,” said council member Habibullah Fawzi. Kabul police spokesman Hashmatullah Stanekzai said the men hid at least one bomb in their turbans, which guards failed to search when the men entered the home.

    Are we talking notes? If anyone thinks that the Taliban wants peace were they do not have control of everything is only fooling themselves.

    Dr. Abdullah Abdullah, a former presidential candidate and Northern Alliance leader, summed up the sentiments heard from many Northern Alliance figures in the wake of the assassination: “This is a lesson for all of us that we shouldn’t fool ourselves that this group, who has carried out so many crimes against the people of Afghanistan, are willing to make peace.”

    Dr. Abdullah added: “We have to be realistic about what we are up against. We are up against people who don’t believe in any humanity. They assassinate people on the streets of Kabul, they assassinate those trying to achieve peace.” Last spring the Taliban had proclaimed that they would kill members of the High Peace Council.

    “No one took it seriously and they should have and it is also time for President Karzai to wake up,” he said. “These are the people who he calls his ‘dear brothers,’ they are behind what happened.” He referred to President Hamid Karzai’s predilection for calling the insurgents “dear brothers” or “upset brothers.”

    If I another video that tries to say some useless feel good message as a legit solution for Afghanistan it will be too soon.

    Here is a interview with the late Burhanuddin Rabbani.

    He was quoted with saying the following below before the suicide bomber attack.

    “Especially in our country, there are a number of individuals who kill Muslims in the name of Muslims. We should take a clear stand against this new phenomenon when the killing of Muslims is seen as something allowable,” said Mr. Rabbani, a former jihadist and Afghan president who, for the past year, had sought in vain to negotiate with insurgents as head of Afghanistan’s High Peace Council