As I’ve previously noted, most folks approaching retirement age probably have already figured out that they’re gonna get screwed by Social Security – e.g., that they will get less value back in benefits than they paid in in taxes. But that’s only part of the issue.
You’re also not going to own a damn thing. Your benefits are completely dependent on the whims of Congress; there is no contractual relationship between you and Social Security. If Congress decides to cut your benefits in half because of future financial difficulties, well, sorry. That’s life, and you’ll have absolutely no legal recourse other than to vote for a different Congressman. And that may not make any difference.
However, spreadsheets and the Internet are wonderful things. I’ve developed a calculator that lets you see precisely what Social Security has cost you compared to a private retirement plan; you can download it here if you like. So now you can see – if you’re so inclined – just how badly you’re getting screwed by Social Security.
This calculator allows you to input your income history. It then assumes that the employee and employer contributions for OASDI – the Old Age Survivors and Disability “Insurance” part of Social Security taxes – are each then invested in an actual retirement account owned by the recipient, with returns based on the DJIA. (And no, insipid – the fact that the Social Security Administration and other elements of the Federal government continue to lie through their teeth and call it “insurance” doesn’t alter reality. Social Security is not and never has been insurance. There’s no contract, no policy, no premiums. Those OASDI deductions from your paycheck are taxes, not premiums; Social Security is a PAYGO income-transfer program and is not any form of retirement savings program or insurance policy.)